A captivating story buried beneath frustrating stealth

I’m a huge Silent Hill fan, and I’m definitely one of those people who doesn’t mind the fact that we don’t seem to be visiting “that town” in the two most recent games. I’ve always believed that Silent Hill itself can present itself in different ways to different people, and that the horrors associated with the franchise don’t necessarily need to be confined to one particular place. For me, Silent Hill has always been more about the psychological torment of its characters than the actual location, and I’m more than happy to see the series explore that idea.

I really enjoyed Silent Hill f and thought there was an awful lot to love about it. Hell, I even had a lot of fun with Silent Hill: Downpour, so when I say I love Silent Hill even at its worst, I really do mean that I absolutely adore this franchise. I’ve stuck with it through some pretty questionable decisions over the years, and I’m generally quite forgiving when it comes to the series trying something different.

That being said, I found Silent Hill: Townfall really difficult to love.

I want to make it clear from the outset that I don’t hate Townfall. In fact, there are elements of it that I genuinely enjoyed, particularly its story, which I found fairly captivating throughout. Unfortunately, there were also some pretty substantial issues that made the overall experience a bit of a slog, and by the time the credits rolled I was left feeling more relieved that it was over than anything else.

The biggest offender here is undoubtedly the stealth, which isn’t just a mechanic that Townfall encourages you to use, but something so intrinsically tied to the game’s ending that it almost feels like you’re being punished for wanting to have fun.

Let’s talk about that stealth, shall we?

For a game that leans so heavily on hiding from its enemies, Townfall really doesn’t do enough to make the act of hiding particularly interesting. Spending extended periods of time crouched in cupboards waiting for one of the whopping three enemy types the game has to offer to wander off got boring within roughly thirty minutes of starting the game. That’s a pretty big problem when you’re looking at an experience that took me around twelve hours to complete.

Essentially, the core mechanic that Townfall is built around became tedious within the first half an hour, meaning I spent the next eleven and a half hours wishing I was doing something else.

Now, I’m not opposed to stealth in horror games. Quite the opposite, actually. There’s something genuinely terrifying about being completely helpless against whatever monstrosity is stalking you, and some of the best horror experiences I’ve had have revolved around knowing that fighting back simply isn’t an option. The problem is that Townfall doesn’t really manage to maintain that tension, and once you’ve spent enough time watching the same enemies patrol the same areas, the fear starts to disappear and is replaced by boredom.

There’s only so many times I can sit in a cupboard waiting for something to walk past before I start questioning whether I’m actually enjoying myself.

And here’s where things get particularly frustrating. Around Chapter 4, I decided that I simply wasn’t bothered about getting the good ending anymore. I’d had enough of sneaking around, hiding from enemies and generally playing the game in the way it clearly wanted me to. Instead, I started whacking and shooting my way through whatever stood in front of me.

And do you know what? I had a genuinely brilliant time doing it.

Suddenly, Townfall became a considerably more enjoyable experience. Combat felt satisfying, encounters became something I actually looked forward to rather than something I wanted to avoid, and I finally felt like I was having some agency over how I approached the horrors the game was throwing at me. It was easily the most fun I had during my entire playthrough, which makes the decision to tie the ending to your willingness to avoid combat all the more baffling.

The fact that you’re effectively punished with the bad ending for fighting back against the enemies, using what I personally found to be the best mechanic in the entire game, really rubbed me up the wrong way. I understand that Silent Hill has always played around with endings based on player behaviour, and I actually really like that aspect of the franchise, but here it felt like the game was actively discouraging me from engaging with the parts of it I enjoyed the most.

Maybe that’s the point, though; Maybe you’re not supposed to get the good ending. Maybe, given everything that’s happened throughout the story, the idea that you can simply fight your way out of your problems is deliberately at odds with what Townfall is trying to tell you. There’s certainly an argument to be made that the game’s approach to violence and its consequences fits within the wider themes of Silent Hill, and I can appreciate that from a storytelling perspective.

Or maybe I’m just apologising for a game I desperately wanted to love.

Speaking of the story, this is undoubtedly where Townfall manages to redeem itself somewhat. Despite my frustrations with the gameplay, I did find myself genuinely interested in seeing how everything would unfold, and the narrative was ultimately what kept me pushing forward when the actual act of playing the game wasn’t doing much for me.

There’s something about Silent Hill’s approach to storytelling that has always resonated with me. The franchise has never been particularly interested in giving you straightforward answers, instead allowing its characters, environments and the horrors they encounter to slowly reveal what’s really going on. Townfall understands that appeal, and even when I was bored out of my mind hiding from another enemy, I still wanted to know what was coming next.

Unfortunately, an interesting story can only carry a game so far when so much of the time spent getting to the next narrative beat feels like busywork. There were long stretches where it felt as though very little was actually happening, and rather than building atmosphere or tension, these quieter moments simply dragged. I appreciate that psychological horror often relies on restraint, but there’s a difference between deliberately unsettling pacing and making the player feel like they’re waiting around for something interesting to happen.

Townfall fell into the latter category far too often for my liking. Ultimately, Silent Hill: Townfall is a game that I wanted to love considerably more than I actually did. I appreciate what it’s trying to do, I enjoyed the story and I genuinely think there’s a good game buried somewhere underneath all that frustrating stealth. Unfortunately, the decision to make hiding such a fundamental part of the experience, while simultaneously offering combat that I found considerably more enjoyable, left me feeling like I was constantly fighting against the game’s own design.

I’m glad Silent Hill is continuing to experiment and I’m absolutely not someone who wants every new entry to simply recreate Silent Hill 2. I want this franchise to take risks, explore different settings and tell stories that challenge what we think Silent Hill should be. Townfall deserves some credit for that, even if I don’t think everything it attempts actually works.

It’s not a terrible game by any stretch, and there’s enough here that I’d still recommend curious Silent Hill fans give it a go. I just wish I’d spent less time hiding in cupboards and more time enjoying the parts of the game that actually worked for me.

6/10